Thursday 3 September 2020

Hatje Cantz Catalogue Essay (September 2020): DECEPTION. i-DESIRE. RADICAL OPTIMISM. Apparatus 22 – art collective

 

DECEPTION. i-DESIRE. RADICAL OPTIMISM

Apparatus 22 – art collective

Text by Mihaela Varzari

to be published by Hatje Cantz


Distinctly eclectic, fractured, non-heterogeneous and multidisciplinary in their approach, Apparatus 22 – a collective comprising artists Maria Farcaș, Erika Olea, Dragoș Olea and the late Ioana Nemeș (1979-2011) – employ a limitless range of everyday materials to create installations, performances, workshops, sculptures, and sound and text-based pieces, as well as interventions in public spaces. Their mishmash of practices and competing visions suggest an affinity with the historic avant-garde, which did not operate with stable barriers between visual art, cinema, music, theatre, costume design or fashion. The group were first brought together in Bucharest by a shared interest in experimental fashion during the early 2000s, before they formed the collective in 2011 as a result of a fortuitous encounter while on an IASPIS residency in Stockholm. In recent years, all its members have lived at different times in Bucharest, Turin and Brussels. With no background in the arts, Apparatus 22 came together motivated by an ethical drive to convey into art their own life experiences as they unfold. Their shared sensibility, informed by critical thinking, places them in the position of the hopeful pessimist, holding to a “radical optimism” (as they label it), which stems from vigilance in the face of the contradictions within an art system immersed in the logic of global late capitalism [i]. 

Vilem Flusser’s hypothesis on history after photography – that its goal is to become an image – resonates with the text-based works produced by Apparatus 22 for their solo show Several Laws: The Elastic Test in 2016. Writing on media and technology in the 1980s, Flusser seems to have anticipated many tropes of our era, which is dominated at all levels by the rampant acceleration of the internet. It is an era especially associated with fake news, which has arisen since Facebook allowed algorithms to select and publish news on its website in 2017[ii]. Such excessive mechanisms of self-deception specific to twenty-first century cognitive capitalism appear to inform Apparatus 22’s text-based works. Destined to engage with the post-internet era,[iii] they consist of condensed poetic texts, not lacking in wry humor. This series are impregnated by nostalgia for unfulfilled desires, which might be considered projections of the self as mediated by intelligent screens. The texts are tattooed on multi-colored canvases made out of stretched, untreated vellum, whose smell fills the entire exhibition space because animal skin, whilst such a versatile material for fashion in the form of leather, retains its olfactory quality when processed for use as parchment. This material, closely associated with the origins of inscription, places the art object at the intersection of a combative relationship between text and body. In the Marxian mode of wanting to change the world rather than merely interpret it, the collective decided to introduce this series of art works into the intellectual and art market with great care, showing caution as to how the works’ financial potential might affect what they wished to criticize; the collective chose their collectors and did not go for the highest bidder. 

Apparatus 22, UNTITLED (5), from SEVERAL LAWS. THE ELASTIC TEST series - exhibition view

object (leather, laser inscription, hand dyed in grey) | 2016 | 100x140 cm; image courtesy of the artists and GALLLERIAPIÙ, Bologna; photo by Stefano Maniero

Positive Tension (in the air) (2012) is a series of five participatory performances that focus on generating conversations with participants. It has since attracted multiple invitations from various cultural institutions across Europe, as well as within Romania itself. In its various permutations this ongoing work includes extensive questions on curating. What could be the biggest pieces of confetti in the world poses questions concerning the role of fashion in consumerism, written on large round multicolored pieces of paper. Thrown in the air in carnivalesque style, the confetti reclaimed for a brief moment the public square of the Museumsquartier in Vienna, for which the performances were initially conceived.

Apparatus 22, Positive Tension (In the Air) performance (in a series of 5 performances in public space) MuseumsQuartier Wien, Austria | 2012; image courtesy of the artists; photo by Laura Paraschiv
 

Apparatus 22 - Art is Work (drawing); Drawing |2012; image courtesy of the artists, MUMOK Vienna and Suprainfinit Gallery, Bucharest

The universal TuTa garment designed by the artist Thayah 4[i] formed the basis for the ongoing project Art is work (2011) 5[ii]. The initial 1919 design resembled a jumpsuit, similar to a worker’s uniform, whose pattern was made available to all in an attempt to unburden clothes from their social status by making them open-source. One hundred or so years later, the same cutting pattern is made available to download by Apparatus 22, who also manufacture the jumpsuits to be given away to artists for immediate wear at art openings. In their own words: “the plain uniform, available to all is an impossible position from which to start thinking about a new project”. It is an utopian ideal, which generates new attitudes vis-à-vis creation, production, distribution, reception and consumption, as well as towards the immaterial labor of late capitalism. Labor conditions are also examined in a quaint way by engaging with the life of magic, in Morpheus Buyback (2011), an elaborate performance and installation, complete with music, furs, seating areas, stories, fears, and desires. The inhabitants of Graz are asked to partake in a gift transaction, specific to archaic tradition, by retelling their nightmares in exchange for good luck charms, customized on the spot. 

 
 
Apparatus 22 - Morpheus Buyback; Installation & performance Drodesera Festival, Italy | 2012; image courtesy of the artists; photo by Alessandro Sala

 

Fashion used as catalyst for reflection and investigation allows Apparatus 22 to delve into a common imaginaire of pre-Christian tradition associated with myths and folklore, which is combined with their outright discontent with the Orthodox Church in Romania, invested as it has been with infinite political influence after the events of 1989. The critique of surplus value as it is produced by the art market maintains the group’s allegiance to utopian ideals, and sustains their particular appeal to political struggle in the related quest to bypass naïve and formulaic anti-capitalist attitudes.


[i] In its variety of instantiations, capitalism produced in Romania after the events of ’89 “nepotistic capitalism”, a self-explanatory term first coined by the former Romanian president Ion Iliescu (1989-1996 and 2000-2004). The Romanian-born writer and political dissident Dumitru Țepeneag (b. 1937), who lives in France, discussed this in his book Capitalism de cumetrie (Nepotistic capitalism) (Iași: Polirom, 2007).

 

[ii] Philip Mirowski, ‘The “logic” of Fake News’, 27 October 2017. At: http://www.perc.org.uk/project_posts/logic-fake-news-philip-mirowski-28th-october [accessed 1 June 2019].

 

3 “Post-Internet Art” is a term coined by the German artist Marisa Olson. See: “On the Internet, No One Knows You're a Doghouse” at: https://www.e-flux.com/architecture/post-internet-cities/140712/on-the-internet-no-one-knows-you-re-a-doghouse [accessed 15 May 2019].

4 [i] Thayaht, the alias of Ernesto Michahelles (1893-1959), was an artist and designer and a pioneer of the Italian Futurist movement in the 1920s.

5 [ii] Art is work by Apparatus 22 was part of the exhibition entitled Situated Knowledge: I follow rivers of thoughts, curated by Anca Mihuleț with the invited Romanian artist Olivia Mihalțeanu, and held at the Romanian Institute for Culture and Humanistic Research in Venice from 15 September to



 

 

Review by Mihaela Varzari (November 2020): Praneet Soi: Anamorphosis: Notes from Palestine, Winter in the Kashmir Valley, at The Mosaic Rooms, London

Praneet Soi: Anamorphosis: Notes from Palestine, Winter in the Kashmir Valley

The Mosaic Rooms Art Space, London

27 September - 7 December 2019

Review by Mihaela Varzari

published with: http://thisistomorrow.info/articles/praneet-soi-anamorphosis-notes-from-palestine-winter-in-the-kashmir-valley

The exhibition ‘Anamorphosis: Notes from Palestine, winter in the Kashmir Valley’ resembles a travelling diary written by a flâneur-cum-researcher, into territories and histories familiar to the artist Praneet Soi. In response to The Mosaic Rooms commission, the artist decided to travel during June 2019 across the Occupied Palestinian Territories including Golan Heights, Jericho and Hebron, and in Israel, in Haifa, Akka andTel Aviv. His aim, the artist states, was ‘to understand productivity and entrepreneurship for people in Palestine’, as was the case in his previous body of work, ‘Notes on Labour’. While working on this exhibition, in August the Modi government revoked Indian-administered Kashmir’s autonomy status. The Kashmiri have been in the middle of three wars between India and Pakistan since the British partition of the region in 1947. Like Palestinians, Kashmiris are treated as second-class citizens in their own land which determined Soi to incorporate local histories from both regions and influences his exhibition of ongoing work with craftsmen in Kashmir.

 Praneet Soi- Anamorphosis- Notes from Palestine, Winter in the Kashmir Valley, The Mosaic Rooms Website - https- mosaicrooms.org.  Credit - Courtesy The Mosaic Rooms. Photo- Andy Stagg

Women street vendors, children attending a fair, young people diving in Akka, an Arabic city situated in Israeli territory and a small business owner populate the film ‘Yalla Yasmeen!’ (2019), which takes the form of a visual essay aimed at registering the minutia of everyday life in the Occupied Territories and Israel. Murad, a hardware store owner just outside of Salfeet in the West Bank, who sells to customers from settlements, talks about ‘the desire of some of them to start a dialogue’. When politics fail, a family business can become a social space for interaction and engagement. Displacement affects all people encountered by Soi in his journey and he mentions how families in his native India return to their hometowns to ensure their children stay connected to the culture. The camera looks at the natural landscape intensely and lingers on an old tree which he considers it to be ‘a witness to civilizations and empires’, creating a slight affectation since the image itself tells enough.

 
Praneet Soi- Anamorphosis- Notes from Palestine, Winter in the Kashmir Valley, The Mosaic Rooms Website - https- mosaicrooms.org  Credit - Courtesy The Mosaic Rooms. Photo- Andy Stagg

Some of the people, plants and natural landscapes featuring in the film from the first room, gain a life of their own and are further immortalised by becoming protagonists in Soi’s drawings presented in the second. Some of these works use silverpoint, a medieval drawing technique that adds to Soi’s specific interest in crafts and responds to his long interest in labour conditions. Almost all his sketching of the surrounding landscapes subtly depicts frontiers and fences. The experience of understanding borders as consequences of illegal occupation, as frustration and obfuscation informs the exhibition design, using a structure allowing points of visibility and sections that are blocked off. This play with ellipsis has been part of Soi’s repertoire for some time through his engagement with anamorphosis. This artistic technique perfected by Hans Holbein the Younger in his ‘The Ambassadors’ (c. 1533) experiments with optics and perspective to create a detail in the painting, namely a human skull, only visible from certain angles. Used as a metaphor, it allows Soi to throw back to the spectator the responsibility for engaging with some uncomfortable states of affairs.

 

 Praneet Soi- Anamorphosis- Notes from Palestine, Winter in the Kashmir Valley, The Mosaic Rooms Website - https- mosaicrooms.org  Credit - Courtesy The Mosaic Rooms. Photo- Andy Stagg

The third room is dedicated to Soi’s collaboration with Fayaz Jan, a master craftsman interested in exploring Sufi history in Kashmir. The tiles presented are made of papier-mâché, a medieval technique imported from Iran, and they feature local, floral motifs. The walls are written on with pieces of legislation from 1948, are reminder of the lack for self-determination on behalf of the Kashmiri.

Soi’s oblique portrayal of social unrest and displacement as a result of occupation brings to the fore the inherent violent nature of representation with all its political entanglements. The incorporation of his artistic research surpasses a well-rehearsed self-curated exhibition and allows new existences for the sketches and drawings.

Praneet Soi- Anamorphosis- Notes from Palestine, Winter in the Kashmir Valley, The Mosaic Rooms Website - https- mosaicrooms.org  Credit - Courtesy The Mosaic Rooms. Photo- Andy Stagg

Post-adevăr-uri (mai, 2020): Liliana Basarab, Mihaela Varzari, Alina Șerban, Robert Bălan, Dragoș Alexandrescu, Vlad Basalici, Livia Ștefan, Carmen Lopăzan

 

Liliana Basarab, Mihaela Varzari, Alina Șerban, Robert Bălan, Dragoș Alexandrescu, Vlad Basalici, Livia Ștefan, Carmen Lopăzan

Post-adevăr-uri este un proiect colaborativ transdisciplinar inițiat de artista vizuală Liliana Basarab, împreună cu Mihaela Varzari (curatoare), Dragoș Alexandrescu (artist vizual), Alina Șerban (actriță), Robert Bălan (regizor, performer), Vlad Basalici (artist vizual), Livia Ștefan (poetă/performer) și Carmen Lopăzan (actriță). Proiectul constă într-o serie de discuții online între participanți, găzduite de Liliana Basarab, urmate de producerea unui material video. Aceste discuții, definite după materialele informative oferite de Mihaela Varzari, au dezbătut implicațiile politice ale epocii „post-adevărului”, urmate de producerea unui performance de către fiecare participant, unde singura condiție este respectarea regulilor jocului de mimă, pentru a transpune în limbaj corporal acest concept. Materialul video final însumează cinci performance-uri ce au la bază conceptul de „post-adevăr”.

 

 

Post-adevăr-uri este unul dintre proiectele castigatoare, ca urmare a initiativei Artists Rooms, proiect menit sa sustina artistii independenti din Romania, pe durata pandemiei 2020. Artists Rooms este un proiect cultural inițiat de Fundația9 cu sprijinul partenerului fondator, BRD Groupe Societe Generale, co-finanțat de AFCN și desfășurat în parteneriat cu Primăria Municipiului București prin Centrul Cultural Expo Art și Anagrama.

 

Liliana Basarab, Vrajitoare (2020), colaj textile.